Anyone else not want Jarrett Jack?

[Vol4ever]

Well I am just giving my opinion and I remember his sophomore season. I also remember the Hawks passed on Tony Parker too. I just believe at this point Law has more upside than Jack. I've watched jack play in the league and I am not convinced he is a PG.

[hawkman]

Quote:

---

Jack actually proved he could play and was ready for the NBA unlike CRitt.

If some one who supports Critt does not want Jack they are insane.

Jack was 10 X the PG of Critt at GT. Jack is ready to play now, Critt may neverbe ready for the NBA as a PG.

---

Keep in mind that Critt was a freshman this past season when you look at his stats. Imagine how good he would be if he stayed in college for another season. He would probably go top 5, somewhere behind D.Rose of course. I really liked Jack at GT too but Critt has the potential to be something special. He was the best player on his team as a freshman. To say that Jack was 10X the PG that Critt is and assume that he may never be able to play at an NBA level sounds a little premature.

[Diesel]

Unfortunately, I believe BK agrees with you.

If you see Conley slip to 11 (very possible) PTL will pull the trigger on this deal. Hell, if you see Green stay in the draft, PTL may pull the trigger on this deal.

[thesheedera]

I'm with Boondocks. I like Jack a lot, 11 feels a little rich though. If we had #15 or 16, that might feel a little better.

I'd take Conley, Hawes and Noah at #11 over Jack without hesitating. I think I might take Crit over Jack for the upside. Law is the huge bogey for me, I can't get my mind around who/what he is. That decision would be a complete guess.

I wish we could have Jack for the present and near future, and one of the three 07 draft PGs for the real future.

[Boondocks]

Trading the 11th in what some call the deepest draft in a long time due to a change in the hs rule, two special talents (Oden, Durant) and the unheard of before FL team staying in college after winning the championship despite all being lottery picks then and now (Horford, Noah, Brewer) is just, well, would rather fit BK's track record unfortunately..

It's a very rich talented draft, to give up the 11th for a player you know to be decent/adequate and an improvement over what we have is a luxury we cannot afford, Hawks simply aren't good enough yet to pull such pranks.

If there isn't a pg you feel comfortable taking 11, take a c, rugged pf or a sg, don't blow it on a role player which Jack is. A good one but not the stellar play maker with good defense some seem to think he is. So a BPA that's not a sf seems to be the route for 11.

After all is said and done, Taurean Green might be just as good as Jarret Jack (albeit smaller) but he's probably a late 1st rounder/ 2nd rounder.

I'd go with Yi or Horford at 3,

if Law, Conley and Critt

a) impress at their respective workouts and of course

b) are available at 11

I'd be much more comfortable but I'd love drafting

Brewer, Noah, Hawes and even Nick Young at 11.

My preference would be 3.Horford and 11.Conley

[pimp]

Quote:

---

Here are the top 50 pg's from CBSsportsworld and Jack is listed 21. Right there with some pretty good talent. Pleae notice that the Hawks have no one in the top 50.

There has also been talk of trading for Duhon, but I'd rather have Jack.

1. Gilbert Arenas, WAS

2. Steve Nash, PHO

3. Jason Kidd, NJ

4. Deron Williams, UTA

5. Allen Iverson, DEN

6. Jason Terry, DAL

7. Tony Parker, SA

8. Kirk Hinrich, CHI

9. Leandro Barbosa, PHO

10. Andre Miller, PHI

11. Mike Bibby, SAC

12. Raymond Felton, CHA

13. Chauncey Billups, DET

14. Stephon Marbury, NY

15. Monta Ellis, GS

16. Rafer Alston, HOU

17. Mo Williams, MIL

18. Chris Paul, NO

19. T.J. Ford, TOR

20. Baron Davis, GS

21. Jarrett Jack, POR

22. Dwyane Wade, MIA

23. Jameer Nelson, ORL

24. Chucky Atkins, MEM

25. Jamaal Tinsley, IND

26. Smush Parker, LAL

27. Devin Harris, DAL

28. Earl Boykins, MIL

29. Mike James, MIN

29. Earl Watson, SEA

31. Derek Fisher, UTA

32. Luke Ridnour, SEA

33. Randy Foye, MIN (Rookie)

34. Jose Calderon, TOR

35. Steve Blake, DEN

36. Jannero Pargo, NO

37. Chris Duhon, CHI

38. Antonio Daniels, WAS

39. Rajon Rondo, BOS (Rookie)

40. Jason Williams, MIA

41. Carlos Delfino, DET

42. Eric Snow, CLE

43. Marcus Williams, NJ (Rookie)

44. Sebastian Telfair, BOS 53

45. Darrell Armstrong, IND

46. Sam Cassell, LAC

47. Carlos Arroyo, ORL

48. Marko Jaric, MIN

49. Keyon Dooling, ORL

50. Nate Robinson, NY

---

What a retarded list.

Jack Being # 21 on this list nothing.

I mean come on, they think Jason Terry is a better pg than

Baron Davis,Dwyane Wade,Chris Paul,Tony Parker.Kirk Hinrich

Andre Miller, Mike Bibby, Chauncey Billups.

We know for a fact that this is not true.