jerrywest Posted March 23, 2009 Report Share Posted March 23, 2009 Decision ----- Then ----- Now hiring Woody ------- C- -------- D- not firing Woody --- F --- D- Diaw -------- C --------- A+ Pryzbilla gone---- B- -------- D- Smoove --------- B ----------- A+ Chillz ----------- C ----------- F Zaza ------------ C ----------- B JJ ---------- B+ -------- A+ Marvin -------- B --------- D- Speedy ------- C- ---------- F Selim -------- B- ----------- F AJ -------- B ----------- C Shelden ------- D+ ---------- F- (expel from school) Bibby ---------- A- ---------- A- Horford -------- B+ --------- A+ Acie ------------- A ---------- Incomplete Calderon ------- A+ -------- A+ (veto from owner) What are your grades? Am I missing any major decision? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Moderators macdaddy Posted March 23, 2009 Moderators Report Share Posted March 23, 2009 Decision ----- Then ----- Now hiring Woody ------- B -------- C - it was a good move at the time and the one we could afford not firing Woody --- n/a --- n/a - he tried at the right time and was blocked Diaw -------- ? --------- ? - your a+ means he was a good pick? I don't have an opinion on this one Pryzbilla gone---- n/a -------- n/a when you clean house you clean house. i don't think we were building around pryz Smoove --------- B ----------- A+ agree Chillz ----------- B ----------- B not bk's fault he left. he's a good player and a good pick Zaza ------------ A ----------- A big man on the cheap. JJ ---------- B+ -------- A+ Marvin -------- B --------- D- ok i'll go with yours Speedy ------- C- ---------- F - hard to fault him for injuries plus he supposedly could be playing now Selim -------- B- ----------- F - this was one pick most seemed excited about AJ -------- B ----------- A - AJ we got for nothing and really stabilized us. Bibby was the biggest reason we made the playoffs but AJ's play early maybe was second. Shelden ------- D+ ---------- F- (expel from school) - terrible. worst move by far but how many believe this was BK's choice. not me. Bibby ---------- A+ ---------- A+ how giving up nothing for a player of Bibby's caliber doesn't warrant an A+ I don't know Horford -------- B+ --------- A+ Acie ------------- B ---------- Incomplete. Rondo was on the board or am i confused? Calderon ------- A+ -------- A+ (veto from owner) What are your grades? Am I missing any major decision? Harrington trade maybe should have brought back a player but we did get a good pick. We gave away Walker but that's a bigger feat than other teams have accomplished. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mattlanta Posted March 24, 2009 Report Share Posted March 24, 2009 Macdaddy, Law and Rondo did not come out of college the same year. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
coachx Posted March 24, 2009 Report Share Posted March 24, 2009 (edited) Typed in my grades in place of yours: Decision ----- Then ----- Now hiring Woody ------- B (Top assistant off Championship team that focuses on defense. ) -------- B (now in the middle of his tenure I really wanted him gone but patience paid off !) not firing Woody --- F --- B Diaw -------- C --------- B Pryzbilla gone---- B- -------- F Smoove --------- A ----------- A+ Chillz ----------- B- ----------- C+ (Not his fault he left for Greece but Deng and Iggy are better) Zaza ------------ B+ ----------- A+ (can't get a more productive big any cheaper then ZaZa's contract) JJ ---------- A -------- A+ ( huge gamble paid off) Marvin -------- A --------- C Speedy ------- B ---------- F Salim -------- A ----------- F AJ -------- B ----------- B Shelden ------- B+ (tried to fill MAJOR need, understood the reach) ---------- F- (expel from school) Bibby ---------- A- ---------- A- Horford -------- A+ --------- A+ (better lucky then good) Acie ------------- A + ---------- C (Still Incomplete) Calderon ------- A -------- B (veto from owner) Add in Solo ............B............B (any 2nd round big who sticks on the roster is a good pick) T. Lue..........B............B clutch shooter on cheap contract......used in trade that brought Bibby Edited March 24, 2009 by coachx Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Premium Member NineOhTheRino Posted March 24, 2009 Premium Member Report Share Posted March 24, 2009 getting Bibby then D --------------- now F+ Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
buckeye242424 Posted March 24, 2009 Report Share Posted March 24, 2009 Decision ----- Then ----- Now hiring Woody ------- C- -------- D- not firing Woody --- F --- D- Diaw -------- C --------- A+ Pryzbilla gone---- B- -------- D- Smoove --------- B ----------- A+ Chillz ----------- C ----------- F Zaza ------------ C ----------- B JJ ---------- B+ -------- A+ Marvin -------- B --------- D- Speedy ------- C- ---------- F Selim -------- B- ----------- F AJ -------- B ----------- C Shelden ------- D+ ---------- F- (expel from school) Bibby ---------- A- ---------- A- Horford -------- B+ --------- A+ Acie ------------- A ---------- Incomplete Calderon ------- A+ -------- A+ (veto from owner) What are your grades? Am I missing any major decision? Interesting post. I question the Marvin grade. If giving him a D- is based solely on his play, no way he's borderline failing. If the D- represents passing on the you know who's for him, then I agree. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Moderators macdaddy Posted March 24, 2009 Moderators Report Share Posted March 24, 2009 Macdaddy, Law and Rondo did not come out of college the same year. Right. I meant Stuckey. I always forget which was in which draft. Although we passed on Rondo too the year before. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Please sign in to comment
You will be able to leave a comment after signing in
Sign In Now